Fantasy Baseball Catcher Rankings 2027 (Dynasty)

Updated . As of today, the top three dynasty catchers are Drake Baldwin (ATL), Rainiel Rodriguez (STL), and Hunter Goodman (COL). The top 61 catchers for dynasty fantasy baseball, sliced directly from our hand-built staff dynasty board of 1000 players, so every C rank below is consistent with where the player sits overall, not a separate list that drifts out of sync.

How We Rank Catchers in Dynasty

Catcher is the thinnest position in dynasty, and this board is deliberately more conservative on catchers than most rankings you'll find, so a catcher ranked aggressively here is a genuine conviction pick. In one-catcher leagues you can afford to wait on the position; in two-catcher formats, bump this entire list up a tier. Players are valued on a multi-year window for 5x5 category leagues, with age, role security, and prospect upside weighed alongside current production. Prospects are ranked inline and flagged (P).

Top 50 Dynasty Catchers 2026

C RankPlayerTeamPosAgeOverall
1Drake BaldwinATLC25#57
2Rainiel Rodriguez (P)STLC/1B19#60
3Hunter GoodmanCOLC26#66
4Shea LangeliersATHC28#71
5Carter JensenKCC23#75
6Samuel BasalloBALC22#84
7William ContrerasMILC28#86
8Cal RaleighSEAC29#110
9Ivan HerreraSTLC26#122
10Gabriel MorenoARIC26#123
11Dillon DinglerDETC28#132
12Josué Briceño (P)DETC21#159
13Alfredo Duno (P)CINC20#171
14Moises BallesterosLAAC22#199
15Vahn Lackey (P)MINC21#204
16Francisco AlvarezNYMC24#205
17Will SmithLADC31#214
18Ethan Salas (P)SDC20#226
19Adley RutschmanBOSC28#269
20Ryan JeffersMINC29#273
21Liam HicksTBC/1B27#285
22Agustin RamirezMIAC25#309
23Keibert RuizWASC28#343
24Ryder Helfrick (P)ARIC21#359
25Dalton RushingLADC25#361
26Kyle TeelCWSC24#396
27Salvador PerezKCC/1B36#415
28Yainer DiazHOUC27#420
29Logan O'HoppeTEXC26#423
30Nathan Flewelling (P)TBC19#440
31Tyler StephensonCINC30#486
32Eduardo Tait (P)MINC20#499
33Austin WellsNYYC27#506
34Joe MackMIAC23#518
35J.T. RealmutoPHIC35#545
36Alejandro KirkTORC27#588
37Carson KellyCHCC32#611
38Harry Ford (P)WASC23#615
39Jeferson Quero (P)MILC23#691
40Sean MurphyATLC31#713
41Caden Bodine (P)TBC22#726
42Owen Ayers (P)CHCC25#730
43Cooper Ingle (P)CLEC/OF24#736
44Franklin Primera (P)BOSC19#741
45Leonardo Bernal (P)STLC/1B22#753
46Axiel Plaz (P)PITC/1B21#760
47Boston Smith (P)SEAC23#764
48Ramon Ramirez (P)KCC21#786
49Endy RodríguezPITC26#811
50Blake Mitchell (P)KCC22#816

Every player links to a dedicated page with expert consensus ranks across dozens of sources, trends, and staff commentary. For the full board with notes on every pick, see the staff dynasty rankings.