Andrew Painter is a deep-league dynasty piece: #231 on the expert dynasty consensus board, the #73 SP, ranked between #130 and #326 across 9 sources. The community rates Painter 59.3 out of 100 on FRV from 321 head-to-head votes, higher than 91 percent of rated players. The community rates Painter higher than the experts do. On the FanRanked staff dynasty board Painter is #243, 12 spots below the consensus. For 2026 redraft, the consensus has Painter #231.
Data as of . Consensus boards refresh daily; FRV moves with every vote. Price any Andrew Painter trade in the trade calculator.
JD, : Andrew Painter is the perfect example of why I hate pitching prospects for dynasty leagues. Here’s a guy who looked lost in the first half of the season and getting sent back down to the minors to throwing 7 incredible innings and touching 99 on his last pitch of the day in his last start. If you’re in a 12 team dynasty league, how would you ever hold onto him in the first half of the season after that abysmal performance unless you were in the midst of a deep rebuild? It’s basically impossible to hold onto pictures when they struggle in the big leagues, whereas hitters, you can give them a little bit of breathing room because you can pick attractive matchups and still get some useful stats out of them. I’m just venting my frustrations right now because honestly Andrew Painter does look really good right now and the bullishness I had when he was a 19-year-old before he got Tommy Jones is coming back again. Just a shame I won’t be the one to experience the upside because I had paper hands and dropped him.
From the FanRanked staff dynasty rankings, a hand-built board updated through the season.
Andrew Painter is a SP for the PHI, Age 23.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Dynasty Consensus Rank | #231 |
| Position Rank | #73 SP |
| Staff Dynasty Board | #243 |
| Redraft Consensus Rank | #231 |
| FRV (FanRanked Value) | 59.3 / 100 |
| Community Votes | 321 |
| Dynasty Rank Range | #130 to #326 |
| Dynasty Sources | 9 expert sources |
| Redraft Sources | 8 expert sources |
Andrew Painter's dynasty fantasy baseball value and rankings, aggregated from expert consensus sources and community voting on FanRanked. Compare where experts rank Andrew Painter, see FRV score trends over time, and analyze source-by-source breakdowns to find value in your dynasty leagues.
Compare Andrew Painter with other dynasty fantasy baseball SPs ranked nearby:
FanRanked aggregates dynasty and redraft fantasy baseball rankings from dozens of expert sources, combined with community-driven FRV (FanRanked Value) ratings from thousands of user votes. Use our full player rankings to compare all players, or try the trade calculator to evaluate dynasty trades.