J.J. McCarthy vs. Michael Penix Jr.: Dynasty Fantasy Football Comparison

J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?

Too close to call in either format. The dynasty trade market prices McCarthy and Penix within 5 percent of each other in superflex and McCarthy and Penix within 5 percent of each other in 1QB, but the expert consensus ranks Penix ahead in superflex and Penix ahead in 1QB.

Data as of . Consensus boards and market values refresh daily.

MetricJ.J. McCarthyMichael Penix Jr.
TeamNYGATL
PositionQBQB
Age2326
Superflex Consensus Rank#108#95
1QB Consensus Rank#190#155
Redraft Consensus Rank#254#207
Expert Rankings (All Boards)1621
Superflex Rank Range#66–#159#64–#152
Market Value (Superflex)21042077
Market Value (1QB)11061092
ADP (PPR 12-team)--
Draft Capital2024 R1 P102024 R1 P8
30-Day Consensus MoveUp 68 spotsUp 12 spots

Production and Projections

2026 Season

StatJ.J. McCarthyMichael Penix Jr.
Games58
PPR Points53.1115.6
PPR Points/Game10.614.5
Pass Yds9151730
Pass TD210
INT27
Rush Yds8594

Week 11 and Rest-of-Season FRANK Projections (PPR)

Week 11 and rest-of-season projections for J.J. McCarthy and Michael Penix Jr., with points, floor, ceiling and position rank, are part of FanRanked Pro, with a 3-day free trial to see them. The top 3 at every position are free on the Week 11 board, and the board moves to the next week every Tuesday.

Price a J.J. McCarthy-for-Michael Penix Jr. trade in the Dynasty Trade Calculator · compare their rest-of-season value in the Redraft Trade Analyzer

Full Player Profiles

Related Comparisons