Dynasty: Payton Tolle. Redraft: Logan Gilbert. The FanRanked staff dynasty board has Tolle ahead, Tolle #33 and Gilbert #43, but the expert consensus has Gilbert ahead (#44 to #51). The community disagrees, leaning Gilbert, FRV 75.6 to 59.4. For 2026 redraft, the consensus has Gilbert ahead, #41 to #112.
JD on Logan Gilbert (May 27, 2026): This is the start of another tier of pitcher for me, I think the theme of this tier is there is either something missing in the profile that doesn't make these arms a premium option or I need to see more of the early flashes on a consistent basis to fully buy in. Gilbert is easily in the first tier for me as I think he is one of the most reliable arms you'll find in the big leagues right now. Feels like he gets bitten by the HR a little bit too much which is why his ERA is in the 3.5 to 4 range consistently rather than in the 3 to 3.5 range and it's hard to expect a pitcher with a 4 ERA to serve as a number one unless you are in a 12-team or more league.
JD on Payton Tolle (Jun 3, 2026): Here is a great article on Tolle and how he has dominated so far. Does anyone else feel like he snuck up on us last year? He was not on my radar at all and all of a sudden he is up and dominating in the big leagues with unreal stuff. with a FB that averages 96 and plays up due to his extension, he doesn't need much else to dominate hitters. Kind of reminds me of Schlitter from the left side with his arsenal.
Data as of . Consensus boards refresh daily; the staff board moves when it is republished.
| Metric | Logan Gilbert | Payton Tolle |
|---|---|---|
| Team | SEA | BOS |
| Position | SP | SP |
| Age | 29 | 23 |
| Staff Dynasty Rank | #43 | #33 |
| Dynasty Consensus Rank | #44 | #51 |
| Redraft Consensus Rank | #41 | #112 |
| FRV (FanRanked Value) | 75.6 | 59.4 |
| Expert Sources | 11 | 11 |
| Dynasty Rank Range | #37–#136 | #41–#70 |
| Rest-of-Season Value | - | - |
| $ Earned Year to Date | - | - |
| ROS Rank (Top 300) | - | - |
| 30-Day Consensus Move | Up 4 spots | Up 4 spots |
| Stat | Logan Gilbert | Payton Tolle |
|---|---|---|
| IP | 186.0 | 148.2 |
| W | 12 | 9 |
| SV | 0 | 0 |
| ERA | 3.73 | 3.03 |
| WHIP | 1.09 | 1.10 |
| K | 205 | 171 |
| K/9 | 9.9 | 10.4 |
Price a Logan Gilbert-for-Payton Tolle trade in the Dynasty Trade Calculator · compare their rest-of-season dollars in the Roto & Redraft Trade Analyzer