Dynasty: too close to call. Redraft: Nick Kurtz. The FanRanked staff dynasty board has them nearly level, Kurtz #10 and McGonigle #12, and the expert consensus agrees (#16 and #10). The community leans Kurtz, 82.2 to 74.5. For 2027 redraft, the consensus has Kurtz ahead, #23 to #39, but Frank's 2027 projection has McGonigle ahead ($23.9 to $19.3).
JD on Kevin McGonigle (Oct 4, 2026): There's a lot to like about Kevin McGonigle after his first season in the big leagues. I wish he could've ended the season with more walks than strikeouts, as that would've been an incredible achievement for a rookie in today's game. As it stood he still walked 95 times while only striking out 100 times. He also really found his power stroke in the second half, hitting 10 home runs across 255 AB (which equates to about a 25 HR pace over a full season) while taking a step back in OBP and walk rate compared to the first half (14.5% vs. 11.9%). That profile plays better in fantasy for sure, and I think the Tigers would like McGonigle to tap into his power stroke more often rather than being passive at the plate. So, what is the risk here? In my opinion there are two paths he can go down. Option A: He is one of the most valuable players in baseball, but the fantasy pedigree never really catches up and his actual 5x5 performance trail his real life value. High OBP, but only 15-20 HR a year with limited SB as he matures. Option B: He continues to improve offensively, keeps turning the gap power into HR power, and maintains a high average while getting to 30 HRs regularly. This is easily a top 5 player imo. If I had to be, I would think he turns into option B, and I'm willing to put all my chips in to acquire McGonigle wherever he is available.
JD on Nick Kurtz (Sep 24, 2026): This ranking should be CJ Abrams' spot, he's done nothing but earn it this year with a 30/30 season. But as the residing president of the Nick Kurtz fan club, it would be irresponsible of me to rank him outside of the top 10 on any dynasty list. I feel like Kurtz is the first player on this list who you can't point to direct production this year to justify their placement in the top 10, which should tell you how I feel about Nick Kurtz's potential. Remember he's only 23 years old and was drafted in 2024 so he has not even entered what should be his prime yet. From this point onward in the rankings, every player is going to have their warts and there is no complete player, so you have to go by upside in a dynasty list like this. Let's talk about his potential upside, he's 98% or greater in the following categories: AVG EV (93.4) Barrel % (18.0%) Hard Hit Rate (57.3%) Bat Speed (78.2 MPH) BB % (18.2%) This profile screams when I hit the ball, I'm absolutely doing damage. I don't think there's a single player in the big leagues outside of maybe Yordan Alvarez and Aaron Judge that have this impressive batted-ball profile, but Nick Kurtz is only 23 years old. Compared to 29 for Yordan and 34 for Judge. The issue is he doesn't always "hit the ball": 32.5% K Rate 36.9% Whiff Rate And both of those stats actually trended worse in 2026 compared to his rookie year, the threat of a low batting average is very real if he doesn't improve on this. If you're at the 10th pick in your dynasty league, all of the surefire bets are gone and everyone has their warts. It's either age, sporadic performance, or some metric in an otherwise reliable skill set that gives you pause. I think Nick Kurtz's combination of youth and upside is the most attractive bet left after the first nine players are spoken for. If your league really values pitching, the Miz is a fine bet at number 10 overall. If you want to put yourself in the best chance to win next year, maybe Yordan is your guy. If you're looking for more of a 30-30 skill set, then I wouldn't fault you for taking CJ Abrams. All I'm saying is don't overlook Kurtz in 2027.
Data as of . Consensus boards refresh daily; the staff board moves when it is republished.
| Metric | Kevin McGonigle | Nick Kurtz |
|---|---|---|
| Team | DET | ATH |
| Position | SS/3B | 1B |
| Age | 22 | 23 |
| Staff Dynasty Rank | #12 | #10 |
| Dynasty Consensus Rank | #16 | #10 |
| Redraft Consensus Rank | #39 | #23 |
| Community Rating | 74.5 | 82.2 |
| Expert Sources | 15 | 15 |
| Dynasty Rank Range | #13–#21 | #7–#17 |
| 2027 Projected Value | $23.9 | $19.3 |
| 2026 $ Earned | $19.0 | $13.0 |
| 2027 Projected Rank | #25 | #49 |
| 30-Day Consensus Move | Down 1 spot | Down 1 spot |
| Stat | Kevin McGonigle | Nick Kurtz |
|---|---|---|
| PA | 707 | 434 |
| HR | 18 | 21 |
| R | 97 | 62 |
| RBI | 72 | 69 |
| SB | 12 | 7 |
| AVG | .278 | .256 |
| OBP | .376 | .396 |
| SLG | .430 | .483 |
| OPS | .806 | .879 |
| wOBA | .357 | .381 |
| xwOBA | .355 | .374 |
Price a Kevin McGonigle-for-Nick Kurtz trade in the Dynasty Trade Calculator · compare their 2027 dollars in the Roto & Redraft Trade Analyzer