Carson Benge vs. Payton Tolle: Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Comparison

Carson Benge or Payton Tolle?

Dynasty: too close to call. Redraft: Carson Benge. The FanRanked staff dynasty board has them nearly level, Tolle #31 and Benge #32, and the expert consensus agrees (#71 and #49). The community rates them even, 62.3 and 59.4. For 2027 redraft, the consensus has Benge ahead, #65 to #131, and Frank's 2027 projection agrees ($23.7 and $15.8).

What the staff says

JD on Carson Benge (Oct 20, 2026): Benge really snuck up on me in the second half of the year and he looks like he's going to be a DUDE. He really flourished after the All-Star break, slashing .311/.375/.475 and crushing 9 HR across 242 at-bats. It seemed like he only got more comfortable as the season went on, and I'm sure he was as bummed as anyone to see the season end as he was picking up steam. There's a little bit of concern for some batting average regression as his BABIP was pretty high at .341, but I think he is finding his power swing and any batting average dip in 2027 should coincide with a power increase. Look for an opportunity to buy low on him at the end April next year, as he started off the season cold in 2026 and sophomore slump whispers might open the buy window. I think Benge is going to be a fixture in the Mets lineup for a long time to come, and this is a shame: the team around him doesn't inspire a lot of hope for the next couple of years.

JD on Payton Tolle (Oct 20, 2026): I was overall really impressed with Payton Tolle this year and I think he has the potential to stick around for a very long time. I made this comment in an earlier blurb a while ago but he kind of reminds me of Schlitter from the left side because he does a lot of his work with the fastball and doesn't need too much else. Between his four-seam, sinker, and cutter he effectively throws a variation of the fastball 88% of the time and both the four-seam and cutter have positive run values, with the sinker being just about break-even, just slightly negative. When you're able to do that from the left side, I really think that you have a long career ahead of you, especially with his 6'6" frame. He also arguably put up his best stats in September, meaning he finished stronger than a lot of pitchers with a full season under their belt would do as they start to hit a wall. The 7th overall SP might be a little aggressive, but his combination of youth and stuff makes him the most attractive starter left on the board after the first six are gone. I feel like you can rely on Tolle to put up great numbers as he enters his prime.

Data as of . Consensus boards refresh daily; the staff board moves when it is republished.

MetricCarson BengePayton Tolle
TeamNYMBOS
PositionOFSP
Age2323
Staff Dynasty Rank#32#31
Dynasty Consensus Rank#71#49
Redraft Consensus Rank#65#131
Community Rating62.359.4
Expert Sources1515
Dynasty Rank Range#43–#130#35–#70
2027 Projected Value$23.7$15.8
2026 $ Earned$21.0$11.0
2027 Projected Rank#26#69
30-Day Consensus MoveUp 5 spotsUp 1 spot

2026 Season Stats

2026 Hitting

StatCarson BengePayton Tolle
PA654-
HR20-
R86-
RBI65-
SB22-
AVG.282-
OBP.346-
SLG.430-
OPS.776-
wOBA.342-
xwOBA.341-

2026 Pitching

StatCarson BengePayton Tolle
IP-148.2
W-9
SV-0
ERA-3.03
WHIP-1.10
K-171
K/9-10.4

Price a Carson Benge-for-Payton Tolle trade in the Dynasty Trade Calculator · compare their 2027 dollars in the Roto & Redraft Trade Analyzer

Full Player Profiles

Related Comparisons